Local
The latest edition
Gathering the headlines…
Connecting you to stories from original sources.
The latest edition
Gathering the headlines…
Connecting you to stories from original sources.
Business · News article
NIAGARA-ON-THE-LAKE, Ontario — A Canadian winery that rushed 200,000 bottles of icewine across the U.S. border to avoid potential tariffs is now considering purchasing supplies from China instead of American companies, raising questions about the long-term impact of President Donald Trump’s trade policies on businesses in New York.
At Pillitteri Estates Winery in Niagara-on-the-Lake, Jamie Slingerland says uncertainty surrounding U.S. tariffs forced his business to accelerate shipments to its five American distributors by four months.
The distributors agreed to store the wine early, but meeting the deadline required additional work and changes to the winery’s production schedule.
“We had to have crews working on the weekends, crews working at night, and we bumped everything ahead,” Slingerland said.
Slingerland said his American distributors were unwilling to absorb the additional costs associated with a potential 50% tariff. Without the early shipments, he feared the winery would have to find other markets for its products.
“Well, we’d have to find a new home for them, that’s for sure,” Slingerland said.
The winery sells icewine in 38 countries, giving it alternatives if selling to the United States becomes more difficult.
Slingerland said approximately 17% of the winery’s business could be at risk. He is also considering changing where the company purchases materials, including glass bottles currently sourced from the United States.
“We won’t be buying glass from the United States; we'll be buying it from China, we'll be shifting a lot of things,” he said.
New York officials warn of economic consequences
The possibility of Canadian businesses shifting their purchases elsewhere is raising concerns among elected officials and manufacturers in Western New York, where cross-border trade plays a significant role in the regional economy.
At a news conference with local manufacturers, Democratic Rep. Tim Kennedy raised concerns about how changing trade policies could affect American businesses.
Stephen Askey of Welded Tube USA said the uncertainty makes it difficult for manufacturers to make long-term investments.
“While trade policies change frequently, it becomes difficult to plan and invest with confidence,” Askey said.
Democratic Erie County Executive Mark Poloncarz expressed similar concerns during an interview with Spectrum News.
“We are a binational region. We have just as much or more in common with our friends across the border in Canada than we do in other parts of the United States,” Poloncarz said.
Poloncarz said tariffs on Canadian aluminum and lumber are adding to cost pressures for manufacturers and homebuilders.
But his larger concern is whether Canadian businesses will establish new trading relationships outside the United States.
“So, I think we’ve seen the Canadians are now saying we’re going to look elsewhere, we’re going to look at Europe, we’re going to look at China as trading partners. And that actually is not good for the United States,” Poloncarz said.
Trump defends tariffs as political landscape shifts
President Trump has defended his tariff policies, arguing that they encourage companies to invest in American manufacturing rather than pay duties on imported products.
“With what we’ve done with tariffs, where businesses are pouring in in order not to pay tariffs, and they’re building factories right now, $22.5 trillion is being invested in the United States right now as we speak,” Trump said.
The president’s investment figure was not independently verified for this report.
His trade agenda has also faced legal challenges.
In February, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act did not authorize the president to impose tariffs under that law.
The ruling limited one avenue for imposing tariffs but did not eliminate the president’s ability to use other trade laws.
Meanwhile, Democrats won control of both chambers of Congress in the November midterm elections, setting up a potential confrontation over trade policy when the new Congress takes office in January.
Democratic lawmakers will have greater authority to hold oversight hearings and pursue legislation challenging the administration’s policies.
However, Trump will retain his veto power, and Congress would need sufficient support to override a presidential veto.
Canadian winery says American customers are still coming
Despite concerns about future trade restrictions, Slingerland said American tourism at Pillitteri Estates Winery has increased by approximately 35%.
He also said the winery has not lost business so far because it was able to move its shipments across the border ahead of potential restrictions.
But the early shipments provided only a temporary solution.
As the winery prepares for future orders, Slingerland said it may need to reconsider where it purchases supplies and which international markets it prioritizes.
For businesses in New York, the concern extends beyond the immediate cost of tariffs.
If Canadian companies establish new relationships with suppliers and trading partners elsewhere, those decisions could have consequences long after the current trade dispute is resolved.
And even if Washington changes course, there is no guarantee that business will return to the United States.